Tuesday, July 25, 2006

Adams League vs. Zotti League

Why is there such a vast discrepancy between the leaderboards in the two leagues? The offensive leaders in the Zotti league are far above those in the Adams, while the Adams pitching leaders exceed those in the Zotti league.

I first thought that the overall totals in the Adams League must be pitching biased while the Zotti league is all hitting. It's not. Here are the league totals.

(Warning, big gap ahead in the text for reasons I don't understand)





























LeagueRunsHRAVGOBPSLGOPS
Adams3973749.255.316.384.700
Zotti3889826.249.320.388.708


They're essentially almost identical.

However, there's much greater variance in both the team totals and in the individual stats in the Zotti League hitters than in the Adams League. For instance, there's only nine hitters with an OPS over .800 in the Adams League. The Zotti League has nine hitters with an OPS over .860. Similarly, the range in team OPS in the Adams League is less than 100 points, while it's over 170 points in the Zotti League.

The situation is somewhat reversed for pitching. The range in team ERA in the Adams League is 2.41 from low to high, while the range in the Zotti League is only 1.61. The Adams League has five pitchers with an ERA of less than 2.50. The Zotti League leader has an ERA of 2.49 and no one else is below 3.00.

I don't have a compelling explanation. I don't think that the best Zotti League hitters are that much better than the best Adams League hitters, nor do I think that the best Adams League pitchers are that much better than their Zotti counterparts. But, it's something that has intrigued me more and more as the year has gone on. Maybe I'm wrong and the best of the Adams pitchers and Zotti hitters are just vastly superior. In any case, I was wondering if anyone else had an explanation.

3 comments:

  1. I don't have the time to plow through the numbers to answer any of your questions, Mack, but it's interesting to see how spread out the top OPS talent is in the Adams League, with five teams represented in the top 5 (and 10), but only one other team besides Nate's and mine is represented in the top 10 of the Zotti League OPS leaders.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Another wierd thing is the errors. The adams league commits many more errors than the zotti for some reason.

    ReplyDelete
  3. With my new database, I can say that historically, that hasn't been true. This is the first year with any remotely significant difference between the two leagues' fielding percentage.

    Actually, this will be the first year with more errors in the Adams League than the Zotti League.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.